Themes and Literary Devices of This Sun on This Rubble by Dennis Brutus

Also Read

 (toc) #title= (Table of Content)

General Introduction

- The poem "This Sun on This Rubble" was written by Dennis Brutus, a South African poet known for his activism against apartheid. Brutus was deeply involved in the struggle for racial equality and used his poetry as a means of resistance and social commentary. The poem was likely written during the height of apartheid, a period marked by severe racial oppression in South Africa. Brutus’s style often combines stark imagery with a poignant, almost lyrical quality, reflecting both the brutality of the world he describes and the resilience of the human spirit.

Title

- The title "This Sun on This Rubble" immediately evokes a sense of contrast and juxtaposition. "Sun" typically symbolizes warmth, hope, and renewal, while "rubble" connotes destruction, ruin, and aftermath. The title sets up an expectation of a moment of solace or reflection amidst devastation, hinting at themes of survival and the lingering effects of oppression.

Themes in "This Sun on This Rubble" by Dennis Brutus

Dennis Brutus's poem "This Sun on This Rubble" is a rich and complex work that delves into several profound themes, reflecting the harsh realities of life under apartheid in South Africa. The themes of the poem include oppression and suffering, resilience and survival, the fleeting nature of hope, and the psychological impact of enduring trauma. Here, we will explore each of these themes in detail.

 1. Oppression and Suffering:

   - Central to the poem is the theme of oppression, particularly the brutal and dehumanizing experience of living under apartheid. The imagery of "jackboots" crunching "bones and spirits" vividly conveys the physical and psychological violence inflicted on the oppressed. This brutal imagery underscores the relentless nature of the suffering endured by black South Africans during apartheid, where their humanity was continually trampled upon by the state's racist policies.

   - The poem reflects a world where oppression is not just a political reality but a daily, lived experience that permeates every aspect of life. The reference to "sweat-tear-sodden slush" further amplifies this, suggesting a life mired in constant hardship, where even the earth itself seems to be saturated with the pain of the people.

 2. Resilience and Survival:

   - Despite the overwhelming presence of suffering, the poem also speaks to the theme of resilience and survival. The very act of finding "some easement" in the midst of such dire circumstances is a testament to the strength and endurance of the oppressed. The "sun" in the title and throughout the poem symbolizes these brief moments of relief and the enduring hope that sustains people even in the darkest of times.

   - This resilience is portrayed as both a physical and spiritual struggle. The people, though "bruised," continue to seek relief and solace, indicating a refusal to be entirely broken by their circumstances. The "sun" provides not just physical warmth, but also a metaphorical light that represents the enduring spirit of those who continue to survive under oppression.

 3. Fleeting Nature of Hope:

   - The theme of the fleeting nature of hope is intricately woven into the poem’s imagery and structure. The sun's appearance after the rain symbolizes a temporary reprieve from the continuous suffering, a momentary glimpse of something better. However, this relief is fragile and impermanent, much like the "sun-stripped" bones that may "later sing" but are also at risk of becoming "malignant nemesis."

   - This theme reflects the reality for many under apartheid: moments of hope and relief were often short-lived, quickly overshadowed by the return of oppressive conditions. The poem captures the bittersweet nature of these moments, where the sun’s warmth is appreciated, but there is an underlying awareness that the darkness is never far away.

 4. Psychological Impact of Trauma:

   - The psychological impact of long-term oppression is another significant theme in the poem. Brutus touches on the deep scars left by constant suffering, as seen in the line "our pride-dumbed mouths are wide in wordless supplication." This suggests a loss of dignity and voice, where the oppressed have been so beaten down by their circumstances that they can only offer up silent prayers for relief.

   - The trauma is also reflected in the ambivalence towards desire: "though we argue against desire," indicating a psychological state where the oppressed have internalized their suffering to the extent that they resist even the thought of yearning for something better. This internal conflict highlights the devastating effects of prolonged trauma, where the desire for change is overshadowed by the fear of further disappointment or pain.

 5. Racial Injustice and Collective Struggle:

   - While not explicitly mentioned, the poem’s context and references, such as "Sharpevilled," clearly allude to the theme of racial injustice and the collective struggle against it. The Sharpeville massacre was a pivotal event in South African history, where peaceful protesters were met with deadly force by the apartheid regime. This reference situates the poem within a broader narrative of resistance against racial injustice.

   - The collective struggle is implied through the shared experience of the oppressed, where the "bones and spirits" of the people are crushed under the same "jackboots." The poem speaks to the commonality of suffering among black South Africans and the shared hope for eventual liberation, even if that hope is fraught with uncertainty.

 6. The Power of Nature as a Symbol:

   - Nature plays a dual role in the poem, symbolizing both the oppression (as seen in the "sweat-tear-sodden slush") and the potential for renewal (through the "sun"). The natural world is presented as both a witness to the suffering and a source of possible relief. The sun, in particular, represents the power of nature to offer solace, however brief, in times of great hardship.

   - This theme suggests a connection between the human experience and the natural world, where the cycles of nature (rain followed by sun) mirror the cycles of suffering and relief in human life. The sun’s warmth is a reminder that, even in the midst of ruin ("rubble"), there is still the potential for moments of grace and beauty.

- "This Sun on This Rubble" is a deeply evocative poem that explores the complexities of life under oppression, particularly during apartheid in South Africa. Through themes of suffering, resilience, fleeting hope, psychological trauma, racial injustice, and the power of nature, Dennis Brutus captures the harsh realities faced by the oppressed while also highlighting their enduring spirit. The poem is a powerful reminder of the human capacity for survival and the persistence of hope, even in the most challenging circumstances.

Literary Devices

1. Metaphor: The poem makes extensive use of metaphor to convey the harsh realities faced by the oppressed. For example, "Under jackboots our bones and spirits crunch" uses "jackboots" to metaphorically represent the oppressive forces of apartheid, while "bones and spirits" symbolize the physical and emotional toll on the people.

2. Alliteration: Brutus employs alliteration to create a rhythmic quality that enhances the poem’s impact. For instance, in the line "sun-stripped perhaps, our bones may later sing," the repetition of the 's' sound mimics the whispering of hope, even in bleak circumstances.

3. Personification: The sun is personified in the poem, described as "glow-lipped" and capable of "sudden touch," which adds a sense of tenderness and unexpected kindness in a world otherwise filled with suffering.

4. Irony: There is an underlying irony in the line "some easement we require unarguably, though we argue against desire." The oppressed, though needing relief, have become so accustomed to suffering that they hesitate to desire better, highlighting the deep psychological scars left by continuous hardship.

5. Imagery: Vivid imagery is a key feature of this poem. Lines like "sweat-tear-sodden slush" paint a graphic picture of the physical and emotional state of the people, making the reader almost feel the weight of their despair.

6. Symbolism: The "sun" in the poem symbolizes fleeting moments of hope and respite, while the "rubble" symbolizes the aftermath of violence and destruction. Together, they encapsulate the transient nature of relief in a world marred by oppression.

Language and Diction

- Brutus's diction is both stark and poignant, utilizing simple yet powerful language to convey complex emotions. Words like "rubble," "jackboots," and "supplication" evoke a sense of harsh reality and vulnerability. The language is formal, reflecting the gravity of the subject matter, yet it carries an underlying lyricism that suggests a deep-seated hope or longing for something better. The choice of words like "glow-lipped" and "sun-stripped" adds a touch of tenderness and suggests the possibility of renewal, even in the face of overwhelming despair.

Mood and Tone

- The mood of the poem is somber and reflective, with an undercurrent of resilience. The tone is one of quiet defiance mixed with weariness. Brutus conveys a sense of enduring pain and oppression, but also a cautious hope for relief, however temporary it may be. The juxtaposition of suffering and the faint glimmers of hope creates a powerful emotional atmosphere that resonates deeply with the reader.

Context

- "This Sun on This Rubble" was written during apartheid, a period of extreme racial segregation and oppression in South Africa. The historical context of apartheid heavily influences the poem's themes of suffering, resilience, and the struggle for survival. The reference to "Sharpevilled," likely alluding to the Sharpeville massacre of 1960, further grounds the poem in a specific moment of brutal state violence against black South Africans. The poem reflects the harsh realities of life under apartheid, where moments of relief were few and far between, and even those were tainted by the ever-present threat of violence and repression.

Conclusion

- Dennis Brutus's "This Sun on This Rubble" is a powerful exploration of the human condition under oppression. Through vivid imagery, metaphor, and poignant language, Brutus captures the stark realities of life under apartheid while also hinting at the indomitable spirit of those who suffered through it. The poem serves as both a lament for the hardships endured and a subtle reminder of the persistent hope for a better future. Despite the overwhelming presence of pain and destruction, the poem leaves the reader with a sense of resilience and the possibility of renewal, much like the sun emerging after the rain.