(toc) #title= (Table of Content)
General Introduction
Mike Alfred is a contemporary South African poet known for his reflective and often introspective style. His poetry frequently delves into the complexities of human relationships and emotions, employing a conversational tone that engages readers directly. This particular poem, "As in: he was a man who had to have a woman," was written during a period when Alfred was exploring themes of dependency and interpersonal dynamics in his works. His poetry often reflects the socio-cultural context of modern South Africa, grappling with issues of identity, need, and connection.
The Poem
As in: he was a man who had to have a woman by Mike Alfred
So you’re the woman he had to have?
[The extra room is built and furnished.]
Did you allow him to have to have you?
[The grass is beginning to grow again.]
Are you the sort, a man who has to have
a woman, has to have? He was there and
you, you were there. There was music
and dancing, so you danced, and you hardly
invented talking, but you used it well, and
walking, too. [The double bed is soft and warm.]
Yes, he’s a man who needs a woman. You’re
not the sort who has to have a man, beyond
a need to be needed. Was it Kismet, you were
there and he was there. You, stirring an adoration
he can’t fully explain; you, with the gorgeous
eyes, you, the figure among the trees and the
clay vessels. You, the woman who sold her
flat and transferred the cutlery. He was
a man who needed a woman and you,
could you have been anyone else, any
other longing, any other neediness?
Title
The title, "As in: he was a man who had to have a woman," immediately suggests themes of necessity and relational dependency. It hints at the idea of a man who defines his existence or identity through his relationship with a woman. The phrase "had to have" implies compulsion or inevitability, setting a tone of urgency and possibly highlighting an imbalance in the relationship dynamic.
Themes
1. Dependency and Need:
- The poem explores the theme of dependency, particularly how one individual feels an almost existential need for another. This is evident in the repeated question, "So you’re the woman he had to have?" which underscores the man's dependency on having a woman in his life.
2. Interpersonal Dynamics:
- The poem delves into the dynamics between the man and the woman, questioning the nature of their relationship and the roles they play. The lines, "Did you allow him to have to have you?" and "You, the woman who sold her flat and transferred the cutlery," suggest a transactional and somewhat unequal relationship.
3. Fate and Choice:
- The theme of fate versus choice is examined through the concept of Kismet, as mentioned in "Was it Kismet, you were there and he was there." This raises questions about whether their meeting was destined or a result of circumstances and choices.
4. Identity and Self-Perception:
- The poem touches on how relationships influence identity. The man is described as someone who "needs a woman," implying his self-perception is tied to having a partner. The woman, on the other hand, is portrayed as more self-sufficient, yet still drawn into the dynamic by her "need to be needed."
5. Emotional Fulfillment:
- Emotional fulfillment and the search for it is a key theme. The man's need for a woman and the woman's acceptance of this role reflect their pursuit of emotional satisfaction, albeit through potentially different motivations.
Structure and Form
The poem is written in free verse, lacking a strict rhyme scheme or meter, which allows for a natural, conversational flow. This structure emphasizes the reflective and questioning tone of the poem. The stanza arrangement is irregular, with varying line lengths that contribute to the poem's contemplative mood. The use of brackets, such as "[The extra room is built and furnished]" and "[The grass is beginning to grow again]," serves to provide contextual asides that enrich the narrative.
Literary Devices
1. Repetition:
- The repetition of phrases like "had to have" and "you, you" emphasizes the themes of need and inevitability, creating a rhythmic insistence that mirrors the man's dependency.
2. Rhetorical Questions:
- The poem is punctuated by rhetorical questions, such as "Did you allow him to have to have you?" These questions engage the reader and highlight the uncertainties and complexities of the relationship.
3. Imagery:
- Vivid imagery is used to describe the setting and characters, such as "the figure among the trees and the clay vessels" and "the double bed is soft and warm." These images create a tangible sense of place and emotion.
4. Irony:
- There is a subtle irony in the portrayal of the woman's role. While she is needed by the man, the poem suggests she may have been "anyone else," highlighting the interchangeable nature of the man's need.
5. Juxtaposition:
- The poem juxtaposes the man's and woman's perspectives, contrasting his neediness with her autonomy. This is evident in lines like "He was a man who needed a woman and you, could you have been anyone else."
6. Symbolism:
- Objects like "the extra room," "the double bed," and "the cutlery" symbolize the domestic and transactional aspects of their relationship, suggesting deeper themes of possession and utility.
Language and Diction
Alfred's choice of words is deliberate and evocative, using plain, conversational language that adds to the poem's intimacy and directness. The diction is formal yet accessible, with occasional use of colloquial expressions like "sort" and "Kismet" to ground the poem in everyday reality. The language is rich with connotations, particularly in the repeated use of "have to have," which conveys a sense of urgency and compulsion.
Mood and Tone
The mood of the poem is contemplative and slightly melancholic, reflecting on the nature of human relationships and the complexities of need and identity. The tone is introspective and somewhat critical, questioning the authenticity and depth of the man's need and the woman's role. There is an undercurrent of irony and skepticism, particularly in the way the relationship is dissected and examined.
Context
The poem "As in: he was a man who had to have a woman" by Mike Alfred is written in a modern context, reflecting contemporary views on relationships, dependency, and gender roles. South Africa, where Alfred is from, has undergone significant social and cultural shifts, particularly in the post-apartheid era. These changes influence the themes of the poem, highlighting issues of identity, need, and emotional fulfillment in a society that is evolving its understanding of gender dynamics and personal relationships. The societal expectation for men to seek fulfillment through relationships with women and the questioning of such dependencies are central to the poem’s message.
Speaker and Point of View
The speaker in the poem appears to be a reflective and possibly omniscient observer who questions and contemplates the nature of the relationship between the man and the woman. This perspective allows for a critical examination of both individuals’ motivations and roles within the relationship. The speaker is not necessarily the poet himself but rather a fictional persona created to explore the themes of dependency and relational dynamics. The tone suggests a mix of curiosity and skepticism, as the speaker interrogates the authenticity and depth of the man's need and the woman's response to it.
Imagery and Sensory Details
The poem employs various sensory details to create a vivid and tangible narrative:
- Visual Imagery: "the figure among the trees and the clay vessels," "the double bed is soft and warm." These images paint a clear picture of the setting and characters, grounding the abstract themes in concrete visuals.
- Tactile Imagery: "The double bed is soft and warm," enhancing the intimacy and physical comfort within the relationship.
- Auditory Imagery: "There was music and dancing," evokes the lively atmosphere where the relationship began.
These sensory details immerse the reader in the poem's world, making the emotional and relational dynamics more relatable and poignant.
Symbolism and Allegory
The poem uses symbols to represent larger concepts:
- The Extra Room: Symbolizes the space created in one's life for another person, indicating preparation and readiness for a relationship.
- The Double Bed: Represents intimacy and partnership, as well as the comfort and warmth that come with companionship.
- Cutlery and Clay Vessels: These domestic items symbolize the mundane, everyday aspects of a relationship, highlighting the practical and sometimes transactional nature of partnerships.
While the poem does not function as a straightforward allegory, it does convey deeper meanings about the nature of human relationships and the societal expectations placed on men and women.
Sound and Rhythm
The poem is written in free verse, lacking a strict rhyme scheme or meter, which gives it a conversational and reflective tone. The natural rhythm of the lines enhances the poem’s introspective quality. The use of repetition, such as "had to have," creates a rhythmic insistence that mirrors the man's neediness. The lack of formal structure allows the poem to flow naturally, reflecting the fluid and often unpredictable nature of relationships.
Syntax and Lineation
Alfred uses varied syntax and lineation to emphasize different aspects of the poem:
- Enjambment: Used frequently to create a sense of continuation and flow, as seen in lines like "a woman, has to have? He was there and / you, you were there."
- Caesura: The poem includes pauses within lines to create a reflective and contemplative tone, such as "Yes, he’s a man who needs a woman. You’re / not the sort who has to have a man, beyond / a need to be needed."
- End-stopped Lines: These provide a sense of finality and emphasis, particularly when summing up key ideas, as in "You, stirring an adoration / he can’t fully explain; you, with the gorgeous / eyes."
Intertextuality
The poem does not contain explicit references to other literary works or historical events. However, the mention of "Kismet" introduces an intertextual element by invoking the concept of fate or destiny, which adds depth to the poem’s exploration of whether relationships are a result of fate or conscious choice.
Conclusion
Mike Alfred's "As in: he was a man who had to have a woman" is a nuanced exploration of relational dependency and identity. Through vivid imagery, symbolic elements, and a reflective tone, the poem delves into the complexities of human need and the societal expectations surrounding relationships. The free verse structure and conversational syntax create a natural flow that mirrors the fluid dynamics of partnerships, while the sensory details immerse the reader in the narrative. Ultimately, the poem invites readers to reflect on the nature of their own relationships and the roles they play within them, questioning the balance between need and autonomy.
Leave a comment behind