A Poem of Poets by James Agee: The poem and Analysis

Also Read

  (toc) #title= (Table of Content)

The poem

The harsh and profitable seasons pass

Bestowing each their own inestimable burdens,

Love its peculiar joy, love's end its proper grief,

Beauty its image, wisdom sought, its pain:

The mind so richly dowered, all withered are its

 guerdons;

Bloodless and sere and joyless, whose hour of green was brief,

They whisper deathly riddles to confused and dying grass:

Soon shall the mind be thoughtless, soon shall the autumn leaf

No more be bright memorial to the ancestral rain.

The mind is stunned, the tongue may find no word,

Nor in themselves may either find ever any thought

Beneath the awful instant of each high visitation,

Beneath the blinding and celestial fire,

Fit to do thankful honor to Him the fire Who wrought:

Wherefore with gilded praises and with false

        lamentation.

We sing into the darkening sky too tardily to be heard,

Who soon shall be brought low to earth and that humiliation

Which gluts the oak with pride and burns the poppy with  desire.

All seasons pass, once more they swerve above,

Once more the mind is granted the living fire to

 breathe

Once more of green and holy and far-gathered leaves fashion straitly implied with brief domestic flowers,

Pride, artifice, despair, our wild half-hallowed wreath:

To crown the mind with fame, and God with  earth-bound passion,

Flaw truth with beauty, make a holy whore of sickened  love:

Once more, and now forever, impends that immolation

Whence we shall rise to damn still other poets with half-blind  power.

The Analysis 

"A Poem of Poets" by James Agee is a complex and introspective poem that delves into the nature of creativity, inspiration, and the human condition, particularly as it pertains to poets and artists.

The poem begins by acknowledging the passage of time and the cyclical nature of life, with each season bringing its own burdens and joys. It speaks of love's joys and griefs, beauty's fleeting nature, and the pain of seeking wisdom. The imagery of the "withered guerdons" suggests a sense of disillusionment or dissatisfaction with the rewards of life.

The poem then shifts to a reflection on the limitations of the mind and language in the face of profound experiences or revelations. It suggests that the mind and tongue are often unable to find adequate words or thoughts to express the depths of such moments, which are described as "high visitation" and "celestial fire."

The poem then explores the idea of artistic creation as a form of homage to the divine creator. It suggests that poets and artists often fall short in their attempts to honor God through their work, resorting to "gilded praises" and "false lamentation" instead.

The final stanza returns to the cyclical nature of life and creativity, suggesting that despite the limitations and failures of individual poets, the creative impulse will persist. The poem concludes with a sense of resignation or acceptance of this cycle, noting that poets will continue to rise and fall, creating imperfect works that "damn still other poets with half-blind power."

Overall, "A Poem of Poets" is a deeply introspective and philosophical poem that explores the challenges and limitations of artistic creation. Through its rich imagery and reflective tone, the poem invites readers to contemplate the nature of inspiration, creativity, and the human quest for meaning and transcendence.